I am a dropout. Maybe you should be, too.
I bailed on my latest writing workshop.
Online workshops are strange beasts. They’re enjoyable, don’t get me wrong, but you have to make sure you don’t lose track of your goals. It’s easy to get caught up with writing exercises, online chats, reading your classmates’ work, and other assignments. You dedicate ten weeks of your time to a class, and if you’re not careful you’ll look up at the end with about two weeks of your own work and a stack of other writers’ first drafts. Eventually, you have to ask yourself if that’s an acceptable outcome after two or three months of effort.
I won’t get too far into that discussion because every workshop experience is different. Let’s just say I’m ready to focus on my own work, I’m selfish, and I couldn’t find the commitment to spend the majority of my time reviewing other work and churning out writing exercises. This ain’t a democracy, it’s not a collaborative effort, and sometimes you have to shut out all the people telling you that there are thirteen better ways to describe how Chester Waddington finds his dead hamster and drops his plate of cranberry sauce.
One thing that bothered me in workshops past was seeing my stories morph into something I didn’t like or recognize. They turned into bad impersonations of authors whose books we were reading. I changed elements I never wanted to change based on class feedback. I lost my way. I lost my voice. There’s a real danger in seeking approval from a pack of strangers.
I’m thinking the same thing you are: Let’s completely overanalyze this! Approval from a pack of strangers. I put that thought on the back burner, celebrated my workshop tuition refund by buying wine and whiskey (hey, that means I’m a writer for sure, right?), and kicked back to watch American Idol. The judges listened to a young woman who walked up and belted out an exact replica of a Celine Dion song, right down to the strange pronunciation of words like “love” (”lerrrrrrrv”) and what I once heard Phil Collins call “excessive embroidery.” When she was done with her mimicry the judges said she sounded great, she was moving on to Hollywood, but they also said something that resonated with me: Throw out your records. Stop listening to what everyone else is doing. Find your voice, and bring that with you for the next round.
This may signal my doom. I may never achieve anything after offending the gods of writing, life, and sensibility by saying this, but that American Idol moment made complete sense. It made sense for my writing…not that I should stop reading altogether, but that I should focus more on my development than worshiping at the altar of any published work I can find.
And you can expand that idea: What is mimicry, and what is you? It made sense on a completely different level. There are times in life when you start sounding like everyone else. You start writing like everyone else. Laughing. Running. Playing. Or worse, you stop exploring those things you love because nobody else pays a lick of attention to them. Cheesy movies. Trashy books. Saturday morning cartoons. Pottery. Poetry. Puttering in your garden. Putting around the golf course. Surfing. Sleeping.
I don’t know if this makes any sense at all. If you asked me yesterday, “Hey, Alex, do you think you can find something useful in an American Idol auditon?” I’d have laughed and thrown bricks at you until you begged forgiveness. But that’s how my brain works sometimes..
Throw out your records.
Posted: January 31st, 2008 under Uncategorized.
Comments: 4
Comments
Comment from KiTe Girl
Time: January 31, 2008, 8:36 am
This is sort of related. But in sports, the best athletes make terrible coaches. Because most of the time they don’t know what they do that is special. They literally “just do it”. I imagine writing is the same. What sets you apart for some other writer is not what you learn in a writing workshop, but what is inside of you that makes you want to write.
Comment from RadioSilence
Time: January 31, 2008, 9:30 am
So you stop when throwing bricks now? Interesting. I see this is a nicer sweeter Alex “The Mortar” Moody than I knew in college.
Comment from Ms. MoodyTunes
Time: January 31, 2008, 9:31 am
I think it’s the same in design. When I was first starting out, I pored over design annuals to find styles that I would copy, but the project inevitably turned out looking amateurish. What works in one application–a certain page grid, type treatment or color scheme–doesn’t always work in another. But mimicking did help me find my own style and discover what works and doesn’t work for me. I’ll probably never be able to pull off a rock band CD cover or design skateboard graphics, but, I can design the s**t out of a resort brochure. So I think it works both ways. In the beginning, you have no choice but to copy, because how else are you going to learn what works best for you unless you try it? But once you find your own voice, that’s when you can start innovating.
Comment from Alex
Time: January 31, 2008, 10:52 am
There’s definitely a school of thought centered on “Just write! Writers write!” and I think there’s a lot to that. If you need excessive coaching, you may be forcing it. But you can also get great feedback from a group of fellow apprentice writers…the tricky part is deciding when to implement changes and when to trust yourself. I think it’s rare to find a writer who sits in a room and churns out hits like Bruce Dickinson (sorry, needed to work “More Cowbell!” into this for some reason). Joyce Carol Oates, maybe?
AND you have to wonder…spend too long in a workshop and everyone starts sounding the same. Even if it’s not on purpose. There’s a whole bunch of talk out there about graduate writing programs churning out hundreds of men and women who write the same stories about the same stuff with the same dark/ironic outlook on incest and cooking and high school angst. It’s easy to fall into that trap. Who doesn’t like a little incest now and then?
The design parallel is interesting, and it really does explain why some apprenticeship and mimicking the masters can be a good thing. You do need someone to show you the way (unless you’re one of the pure talents, and in that case, screw you).
Regarding throwing rocks…I had a great teacher. He came from the land of angry rock-throwers and helped me perfect my form. I won’t mention any names like RadioSilence but I definitely got my protest-march toss from that guy. It’s in his blood.
Write a comment